Italian Cream Sheet Cake

The moment you slice into Italian cream sheet cake, you're greeted with a symphony of textures – moist, tender crumb giving way to creamy frosting and the pleasant crunch of pecans. This Southern classic combines buttermilk-enriched cake with coconut, and tangy cream cheese frosting to create a dessert that feels celebratory yet comforting. Each bite delivers the perfect balance of sweetness and richness without overwhelming your palate.

I first encountered this cake at my grandmother's table during summer family reunions. While traditional Italian cream cake is often made as a layer cake, her sheet pan version was practical for feeding our large family while maintaining all the decadent flavor. I've been perfecting this recipe ever since, and it's become my signature dessert for gatherings large and small.

Essential Cake Components

• All-purpose flour (3 cups): Creates the perfect structure; measure by spooning into cups and leveling for accuracy
• Buttermilk (1 cup): Provides tenderness and subtle tang; real buttermilk yields superior results to substitutes
• Egg whites (4): Whisked separately to incorporate more air during beating
• Cream cheese (1 cup, softened): Forms the foundation of the frosting; always use full-fat for the creamiest results
• Sweetened coconut (1 cup): Adds moisture and texture; freshly grated coconut provides the best flavor
• Pecans (1 cup, chopped): Contributes essential crunch and nutty flavor; freshly chopped pecans provide superior texture
• Brown sugar (1 cup): Brings depth and moisture that white sugar alone cannot provide
• Vanilla extract (1 teaspoon): Enhances all other flavors; pure extract rather than imitation makes a noticeable difference
• Salt (1/2 teaspoon): Enhances flavors and balances sweetness

Creating Cake Magic

Preparation Foundation:

Preheat your oven to exactly 350°F, positioning rack in the center. Line your baking pan completely with parchment paper, leaving overhang on two sides for easy removal. Lightly grease with butter or cooking spray.

Dry Ingredient Assembly:

Whisk flour, baking soda, and salt together thoroughly in a large bowl, ensuring even distribution of leavening agents. This prevents uneven rising and bitter spots in the finished cake.

Butter Mixture Development:

Beat softened butter, oil, and both sugars in a separate bowl until completely smooth and slightly lightened in color, approximately 3-4 minutes. This creates air pockets essential for proper cake structure.

Yolk Incorporation:

Add egg yolks individually, beating thoroughly after each addition. This gradually emulsifies the fats and creates a smooth, stable base. Scrape down sides of bowl frequently to ensure even mixing.

Alternating Additions:

Add dry ingredients and buttermilk in alternating portions, beginning and ending with flour. Mix gently just until incorporated, being careful not to overmix which would develop gluten and toughen the cake.

Coconut Integration:

Fold in shredded coconut by hand using a rubber spatula, distributing it evenly throughout the dough.

Egg White Technique:

In a completely clean, grease-free bowl, whisk egg whites until they form stiff peaks that hold their shape. Fold into batter gently using a figure-eight motion to preserve as much air as possible.

Final Assembly:

Spread batter evenly into prepared pan, smoothing the top with a spatula. The relatively thin layer will form the fudgy foundation for your cake-frosting hybrid.

Frosting Creation:

In a separate medium bowl, beat softened cream cheese with electric mixer until completely smooth and free of lumps, approximately 2 minutes. This incorporates air for proper frosting texture. Add powdered sugar gradually while continuing to beat, then incorporate egg and vanilla until the mixture looks silky and light.

Final Assembly:

Pour frosting mixture evenly over the cake batter, using an offset spatula to create a smooth, even layer. Sprinkle chopped pecans across the surface, then create artistic swirls with a knife or skewer, drawing it through all three layers without overmixing.

Save

My grandmother taught me the value of patience when making layered desserts. I still remember how she would gently swat my hand away when I tried to cut into her famous cakes before they had properly cooled. 'Good things come to those who wait,' she'd say with a knowing smile. With this Italian cream sheet cake, that wisdom certainly applies—the texture improves dramatically with proper cooling time, transforming from a hot, gooey mess into perfect, sliceable squares with distinct layers.

Perfect Pairings

This versatile cake shines in various presentations to suit any occasion. For breakfast or brunch, serve thick slices lightly toasted and spread with softened salted butter alongside fresh berries. Summer entertaining calls for accompanying slices with macerated strawberries and freshly whipped cream for an elevated strawberry shortcake experience. During holiday seasons, garnish with sugared cranberries and mint leaves for a festive appearance. For dinner parties, plate individual slices with a light dusting of powdered sugar and a quenelle of vanilla bean ice cream.

Creative Variations

Adapt this flexible recipe to create exciting flavor combinations that maintain the Italian theme. Coconut enthusiasts might add ½ cup toasted shredded coconut to the batter and substitute coconut extract for vanilla. Create a Mediterranean-inspired version by adding sun-dried tomatoes, chopped fresh basil just before serving, and a splash of limoncello. For mushroom lovers, sauté sliced mushrooms in butter until golden, then fold into the batter before adding the buttermilk. Create an Italian version with basil, oregano, and a splash of Marsala wine in the batter. For spice enthusiasts, incorporate diced jalapeños and a dash of cayenne pepper alongside the other seasonings.

Storage Solutions

Maintain the freshness and flavor of leftover cake with proper storage techniques. Keep refrigerated in an airtight container for up to 3 days, separating layers with parchment paper to prevent sticking. For longer storage, freeze individual portions in freezer-safe containers for up to 2 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before bringing to room temperature and frosting for best results. For meal prep purposes, store the cake and frosting separately, combining just before serving for optimal texture.

This Italian cream sheet cake has become my signature dessert for gatherings where I want something reliable yet special. What continues to amaze me is how something so simple can transport you instantly to a sunnier state of mind. The combination of buttery sheet cake with sweet-tart cream cheese frosting creates an experience greater than the sum of its humble parts—proof that sometimes the most straightforward recipes yield the most memorable results.

Save

Common Questions About Cooking

→ Can I make this cake without pecans?

Absolutely! As mentioned in the recipe, you can omit the pecans completely and the cake will still be delicious.

→ Why do I need to separate the eggs?

Separating the eggs allows you to whip the whites separately, which creates a lighter, more tender cake texture when folded into the batter.

→ Can I make this cake ahead of time?

Yes! This cake actually tastes even better the next day. Store it covered in the refrigerator for up to 3-4 days.

→ Can I substitute the buttermilk?

If you don't have buttermilk, mix 1 tablespoon of vinegar or lemon juice with enough regular milk to make 1 cup and let it sit for 5 minutes.

→ Why is it called Italian Cream Cake?

Despite the name, this cake isn't actually Italian in origin. It's a traditional Southern American cake that became popular in the mid-20th century.