Save
I created this sugar cookie cheesecake one December afternoon when I couldn't decide between cookies and cheesecake. The moment that creamy vanilla filling studded with bits of sugar cookie dough came out of the oven I knew I'd found something special. That buttery shortbread crust and tangy sour cream topping make it feel like Christmas in every slice. Now my family begs for it as soon as the holiday season starts.
A Holiday Dream Come True
Every time I serve this cheesecake people can't believe how the flavors work together. The way that buttery crust supports the creamy filling while little bites of sugar cookie dough surprise you throughout it's pure magic. That sour cream frosting adds just the right touch of tang to balance all the sweetness. It's become the dessert everyone talks about long after the holidays are over.
Everything You'll Need
The magic starts with that shortbread crust cold butter and flour create the perfect foundation. For the cookie dough I always let my butter come to room temperature it makes such a difference in the texture. The cheesecake itself needs plenty of cream cheese make sure it's completely soft before starting. My secret weapon is a touch of almond extract along with vanilla it adds this subtle special something. The sour cream frosting brings it all together with just the right balance of sweet and tangy.
Let's Make Magic
Start with that gorgeous shortbread crust pressing it carefully into your pan. While it bakes roll those cookie dough pieces they're like little treasures waiting to be found. When you're mixing the cheesecake batter go slow and steady no rushing here it keeps everything smooth. The water bath might seem fussy but trust me it's worth it for that perfect texture. Watching the frosting spread over the top is my favorite part especially when those festive sprinkles catch the light.
Save
My Best Baking Tips
After many holiday seasons making this cheesecake I've learned a few tricks. Room temperature ingredients are non negotiable they blend so much better. That parchment paper liner is your best friend for easy removal. Don't worry if you see tiny cracks around the cookie dough pieces it's totally normal and adds to the charm.
Common Questions Answered
My gluten sensitive friends love this with gluten free flour and a bit of cornstarch in the filling. You can definitely make it ahead it actually gets better after a day in the fridge. Sometimes I switch things up and make it with chocolate chip cookie dough the possibilities are endless once you get the technique down.
Common Questions About Cooking
- → Why does the cheesecake need to chill overnight?
- Overnight chilling allows the cheesecake to fully set and develop its texture. This ensures clean slices and the best flavor development.
- → Why use a water bath for baking?
- The water bath creates a moist environment that helps prevent cracking and ensures even baking of the cheesecake filling.
- → Why might the surface crack?
- The cookie dough pieces in the batter can cause some surface cracking, but this is normal and will be covered by the frosting.
- → Can I make this ahead of time?
- Yes, this cheesecake needs to chill overnight and can be made 2-3 days ahead. Add the frosting and sprinkles just before serving.
- → Why must ingredients be room temperature?
- Room temperature ingredients blend more smoothly and create a more uniform cheesecake batter without lumps.